The Don’ts and Do’s of Pet Food and Treats

Just because a pet food company sponsors dog shows or donates to pet adoption doesn’t guarantee they are selling high quality pet foods and treats.  Here’s a list of Don’ts and Do’s (do ask) that every pet owner should consider before they purchase any pet food or treat.

The following list is the don’ts…don’t purchase a pet food with any of the following ingredients in it (and why!).

No by-products.  By-products, by official AAFCO definition, are bits and pieces of slaughtered animals not suitable and/or not desirable for human consumption; by definition this ingredient is NOT MEAT.  You can consider by-products garbage from the processing of human food.  Do you really want to spend good money to purchase someone else’s garbage?

No by-product meal.  By-product meal is slightly different than by-products because this ingredient can also include meat; however it would most likely be meat from an animal that was rejected for use as human food (because of disease, drugs, ect).  Again, do you really want to spend good money for someone else’s garbage?  (This ingredient in a pet food could make the food in violation of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act; which should make it prohibited for sale.)

No meat and bone meal.  This pet food ingredient could contain any euthanized animal, expired grocery meat, used restaurant grease.  The FDA determined this ingredient probable to contain pentobarbital; a lethal drug used to euthanize animals.  (This ingredient in a pet food could make the food in violation of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act; which should make it prohibited for sale.)

No meat meal.  This pet food ingredient could contain any euthanized animal, expired grocery meat, used restaurant grease.  The FDA determined this ingredient probable to contain pentobarbital; a lethal drug used to euthanize animals.  ‘Meat meal’ is a completely different ingredient than a meat specific meal such as ‘Chicken meal’ or ‘Turkey meal’.  Specific meat meals (chicken meal as example) provide quality protein; un-specific meat meal provides protein, however the quality is highly questionable.  (This ingredient in a pet food could make the food in violation of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act; which should make it prohibited for sale.)  (More on meat specific meals below in Questions to Ask.)

No Animal Fat.  In the cooking process (rendering) of either of the above ingredients, the fat that rises to the top during cooking becomes ‘animal fat’.  The FDA determined this ingredient probable to contain pentobarbital; a lethal drug used to euthanize animals.  Specific animal fats such as Chicken Fat are optimal.  (This ingredient in a pet food could make the food in violation of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act; which should make it prohibited for sale.)

No animal digest.  Similar to meat and bone meal.  The FDA determined this ingredient probable to contain pentobarbital; a lethal drug used to euthanize animals.  (This ingredient in a pet food could make the food in violation of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act; which should make it prohibited for sale.)

No BHA.  Chemical preservative linked to serious illness.

No BHT.  Chemical preservative linked to serious illness.

No Ethoxyquin.  Chemical preservative linked to serious illness. (More on this preservative in Questions to Ask below.)

No TBHQ.  Chemical preservative linked to serious illness.

No dyes.  Dyes are used in some pet food/treats ONLY to please the eye of the pet owners.  Many dyes are questioned to be safe.

No corn, wheat, or soy (or any other) glutens.  Glutens or vegetable proteins are frequently sourced from China.  These vegetable proteins were the source of melamine contamination causing the deaths of thousands of pets in 2007.  Vegetable glutens provide the pet little to no quality nutrition.

No corn, wheat or soy in any form.  Chances are, any corn, wheat or soy ingredient (whole grain, flour, whatever form) is a genetically modified grain.  Recent studies of three GM corn varieties fed to rats over only 90 days showed kidney and liver problems.  Imagine what could happen to a pet eating a GM grain everyday for years?

No Menadione Sodium Bisulfite.  This is a synthetic Vitamin K.  German studies link this ingredient to serious side effects.  Why use a synthetic Vitamin K when a natural source of Vitamin K is so easy to add?

No Sodium Selenite (dogs).  Selenium is a necessary and required nutrient.  Sodium Selenite is one form of providing selenium to a pets diet.  Sodium Selenite is highly toxic in larger doses (should human error occur).  Selenium yeast on the other hand is not considered toxic in larger doses (should human error occur).  Selenium yeast has not been approved for use in cat foods, however some manufacturers still use this ingredient in cat food (understanding the safety concerns of sodium selenite).  Look for selenium yeast in pet foods versus feeding a food with sodium selenite.

Can foods no carregeenan.  Added to some canned pet foods and treats to bind ingredients; carregeenan is linked to cancer in recent studies.

Ok, now that you’ve avoided the pet foods/treats that contain risk ingredients, before you make that purchase you need a bit more information from the manufacturer.  If they don’t answer your questions promptly and directly, don’t purchase their food.  

Ask…
(1) Are the meat ingredients in your pet food/treat the same quality (USDA approved) as the meat found in my grocery?
(Caution:  Some shifty pet food manufacturers using by-products will answer this question “yes, our meats come from USDA approved facilities”.  Do you see the trick answer?  Animals rejected for use in human foods come from USDA approved facilities however rejected meat is not USDA approved meat.  Don’t let them trick you.)

(2)  Do all ingredients in your pet food/treat originate from the U.S.?  Including vitamins and minerals?
(Caution:  Many pet food manufacturers will respond yes if you don’t specifically ask about country of origin of vitamins and minerals.  Many vitamins and minerals used in pet food/treats are sourced from China.  Do you really want to take the chance with Chinese vitamins and minerals?)
Most all lamb and venison in pet food/treats is sourced from New Zealand.  This is a safe country of origin.

(3) What is the shelf life of the cat food/dog food?
All pet foods have a ‘Best by’ date stamped on the packaging.  However, every pet food manufacturer varies in how long the food is considered ‘best by’ or shelf life.  As example, one food might have a shelf life of one year, another might have a shelf life of three years.  When you look at the ‘Best by’ date on the packaging and it’s six months in the future, with one food that means the food was made six months ago, with the other food that means the food was made two and a half years ago.  Fresher food provides your pet with higher quality nutrition.  Learn the shelf life of the pet food to know exactly how fresh the food is you are purchasing.

(4) Who makes the foods/treats and where is the plant(s) located?
Some pet foods/treats are manufactured at another pet food company’s plant; the ‘making’ of the food is sort of sub-contracted.  Other pet food manufacturers own their own manufacturing plants for dry and canned foods.  A pet food company owning its own manufacturing plant does not make a pet food/treat better or worse; but, it is information you deserve to know.

If the pet food has a specific meat meal ingredient such as Chicken Meal…
(5)  Does your Chicken Meal (or other meat meal ingredients) contain muscle meat only or does it contain internal organs and/or bone?
A recent study from EWG.org showed a link to high levels of fluoride to bone ingredients in pet foods.  High levels of fluoride is linked to bone cancer.  Meat meals using muscle meat only would have lower fluoride levels.

If the pet food has a fish meal or fish oil ingredient (not a fish ingredient, fish ‘meal’; and any fish meal variety or fish oil)…
(6) What does your fish meal and/or fish oil supplier use as a preservative?  Is it ethoxyquin?  If not, what preservative is used?
Here’s a perfect example of how tricky pet food can be.  If the pet food manufacturer does not add a ingredient to the food, it does not have to list it on the label.  So…if a fish meal supplier adds a preservative (required by law), the pet food manufacturer is not required to state that preservative on the pet food label; even though it’s in the food/treat.  Some pet food companies insist on natural preservatives such as Naturox or mixed tocopherols, others use risky chemical preservatives such as ethoxyquin.  

If the pet food is canned…
(7) Do your pet food cans contain a BPA lining?
BPA or Bisphenol A is a chemical in plastic commonly used as a liner in canned foods.  Recent studies have proven a link between consumption of BPA (chemical leeches into the food) and serious illness.

Don’t purchase a pet food/treat without knowing all the above information first. 

 

Wishing you and your pet(s) the best,

Susan Thixton
Truth about Pet Food
Petsumer Report
www.TruthaboutPetFood.com

Are you subscribed to Truth About Pet Food Newsletter?
Receive future pet food articles and alerts delivered to your email box. Click Here to subscribe. Your privacy is guaranteed - your email address will not be sold or shared. 

What's in Your Pet's Food?
Is your dog or cat eating risk ingredients?  Chinese imports?  Petsumer Report tells the 'rest of the story' on over 1700 cat foods, dog foods, and pet treats.  For each review you'll discover if ingredients are U.S. only or imported, human quality meat or pet grade meat, shelf life, red flag or risk ingredients, and recall history.  New reviews added monthly.  30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee.  www.PetsumerReport.com

Follow Truth about Pet Food on Twitter.  To follow TAPF on Twitter...Under People Search, look for Susan Thixton or TAPF (Truth about Pet Food was too long for Twitter).  Instant pet food updates should an emergency occur.  www.Twitter.com/TAPF

Become a Fan of Truth and Vindication on Facebook.  TruthaboutPetFood Fan click here.  Vindication Fan click here.

Independent Pet Food Store Listings are here!  To find quality dog food and cat food in your area...Click Here.


Comments (6)

Said this on 5-3-2010 At 01:10 pm

I'm a little bummed that I don't see my last comment posted - guess something went wrong with that one. I had pondered about the fluoride in bone meal issue - it occurred to me that since fluoride is stored in bone, would raw feeders have to worry about all of the bone we feed? No one really knows what levels of fluoride are considered high for dogs (hey doctoral students - what about a study on dogs with osteosarcoma - do they have higher levels of fluoride in their systems than healthy dogs?) and I'm sure no raw food companies are testing for fluoride in their bones.

I decided just for fun to contact the raw food companies I know with this question, just to see how they'd respond. I didn't expect them to have a good answer to this, and didn't expect them to have really thought about it at all - just putting it out there to see what kind of answers I'd get. My general question:
Hello - I've been pondering the report from the EWG about the levels  
of fluoride in meat and bone meals
(http://www.ewg.or/pets/fluorideindogfood) - I'm wondering what this might mean for those of us who feed raw  
(and I advocate RMB every day in my store). Do you have a feeling  
about whether there is a risk of high fluoride levels in bones? Do you  
test for it? I don't think there have been studies yet on fluoride  
levels in pets, but it does make me wonder about it.
Thanks
Christine Mallar
Green Dog Pet Supply
Portland OR

The most disappointing response I got was from Nature's Variety, though I know when you're dealing just with customer service and not with the owners or the nutritionists themselves, you're probably not going to get very far on an issue that isnt very pressing. They said:
Dear Christine,
 Thanks for emailing!  The studies presented used foods with high levels of meat and bone meal in addition to by-product meal and other inferior ingredients.  Our foods are holistic and as a result do no use inferior ingredients or fillers and are safe to feed.
Sincerely,
Customer Service
Nature's Variety
www.naturesvariety.com

The best responses have been from Bravo:
Hi Christine

I have thought a lot about your email since I first read it.  
My answer is that I do not know what the risks might be with regards to
fluoride and RMB. It does bring up an interesting question and one that I
have not thought of before.  It is something that hasn't really been studied
before so it is impossible for me to make an informed decision on. I do have
my personnel feelings on Fluoride and I am sure that are not far from yours.


Because the use of fluoride is so wide spread in this country it is
impossible to get away from.  We do not test for it and it would be
impossible to do so. We get our meats from various sources and farms.  If we
were to test specifically for fluoride we would have to run a nutritional on
every batch.  There is no company pet or human that runs nutritionals on
every batch of food that they process.  We as a society could not afford the
cost that it would add to the product. FYI, a standard nutritional is
$1500/.00 to $2300.00.

So we are left with trying to do the best that we can.  We are now
processing most of our lamb and beef in New Zealand. While they do use
fluoride in their drinking water their methods of farming are so vastly
different from ours. They get a lot of their water for their farms from the
lakes/streams/wells as oppose to water that has fluoride added into it. The
rest of our products are from the cleanest sources that we can get but they
are from the US and are most likely fed water that does contain fluoride.

I wish I had a better answer for you.
Bette Schubert
Bravo Raw Diet
1084 Hartford Turnpike
Vernon, CT 06066
866-922-9222
www.bravorawdiet.com
HI there and thanks so much for contacting us.
I do test the bones and bone marrow for arsenic and lead- we've always gotten  NOT DETECTABLE level- well since we went to the Organic beef bones- though our bones aren't labeled as such since there isn't a use for USDA certified organic beef bones- the California state department of ag won't inspect and certify for us ( we get our bones from Panorama Meats out of Modesto CA- the same cows that our Organic beef comes from- they are a wonderful group of farmers that 100% grass feed, never brought into a feed lot growers! I love them)
in fact only when I first started and didn't understand how the marrow gets contaminated, and we didn't "selectively" buy our bones did I ever see levels of arsenic and lead, never fluoride. I will read the article you've brought to my attention and look into the options for fluoride testing...
again, thanks so much for your time and efforts to research for the benefit of our companions and customer security.
 
Ara Bush
President
Raw Advantage, Inc
PO Box 456, Kettle Falls, WA 99141
Office: 509.738.3344
Fax: 509.738.3343
www.RawAdvantagePetFood.com

I just like it when anyone takes the time to consider a question for what it is and responds thoughtfully - it certainly makes me respect the company more, and also reminds me of the value of dealing with smaller companies when possible - both of these good responses are from the owners themselves.

Sorry about the length of this comment - just figured you all might enjoy seeing how companies responded. Still a number that haven't yet.

Yruakey
Said this on 5-11-2010 At 08:47 pm

A few things stood out to me as being misleading from this article. 

1) The definition of a "by-product"  The true AAFCO definition is "secondary products produced in addtion ot the principal product."  This being said, if the principal product a company is processing for is chicken wings then the perfectly good chicken breasts are technically considered a "by-product".  Also vitamin E is a by-product of soy bean processing.

2)  USDA quality ingredients--once any product leaves a USDA regulated facility it is technically no longer USDA quality/protected.  And along those lines, AAFCO has determined that any pet food claiming to have "human grade" is false or misleading.  Pet food companies can not put a "human grade" claim anywhere on their packages since they are AAFCO regulated.  However, they can plaster is all over their websites or marketing materials b/c AAFCO has no regulating authority over those locations.  In order to be "human grade", the food must be something that you or I would be willing to eat and I don't know of many people willing to put a pet food into their rotation of meals.

And finally, 3) this is one I semi-agree with but would like to expand on-- (5)  Does your Chicken Meal (or other meat meal ingredients) contain muscle meat only or does it contain internal organs and/or bone?-- not only is it possible for fluoride levels to be higher (which those values won't be on the label) but also poor quality meat meals will drive up the calcium and phosphorous levels in the diet b/c of the extra bone material, and high levels of calcium and phosphorous are deterimental to our pet's internal organs especially the kidneys.  Cheaper pet foods tend to be higher in these mineral components b/c the meat meal is of lower quality because it too is cheaper.  Pet food company must spend more on their meat meal to ensure a lower mineral content that is appropriate for our companion animals, therefore, buying higher quality meals means the diet is going to cost the pet owner more. 

Just some thoughts to consider when comparing various pet foods out there on the market. 

Said this on 9-3-2010 At 12:09 pm

Usually I do not post on blogs, but I would like to say that this article really forced me to do so! Thanks, really nice article.


gc
Said this on 10-14-2010 At 08:55 am

Your complaint of carregeenan is a non-issue. no reports have been found with cancer induction, but rather something else entirely. it is used in ice creams for humans and made from seeweeds. you should also cite your sources. 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrageenan

Susan Thixton
Said this on 10-14-2010 At 11:58 am

Sources found here: http://www.truthaboutpetfood.com/articles/what%E2%80%99s-this-ingredient-in-my-pet%E2%80%99s-food--carrageenan.html

If you have read much on this website, you'll see I rarely, if ever, simply pass opinion...sources are always provided when I report on pet food ingredients.

Nan
Said this on 7-7-2011 At 04:49 am

Thank you so much for this article. I will only feed my dogs food with selenium yeast. I hope you can answer this question. My dogs were on Orijen 75% and where doing well until they changed their formula to 80% and all 3 of my dogs are getting sick on it. My question is when I got onto their website they show selenium yeast but on their new bags of 80% sodium selenite is listed. They are saying its a mistake on the bags and the new bags will have selenium yeast. It has been over a year and still sodium selenite is listed. How are they getting away with this? The company is in Canada. Also, when I got on other sites a lot of people are saying their dogs are getting extremely sick on their new formula.

Thanks,

nan

Post a Comment (showhide)
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
(not publicly displayed)
Reply Notification:
Approval Notification:
Website:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image:
* Message:

Email to Friend

Fill in the form below to send this article to a friend:

Email to Friend
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
* Friend's Name:
* Friend's Email:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image
* Message: