U.S. Senator Calls FDA on the Carpet with Chinese Jerky Treats

Someone in Congress is taking a stance for pet parents with the situation of Chinese imported jerky treats; Senator Sherrod Brown.

U.S. Senator Sherrod Brown (Ohio) has issued the following statement...

February 6, 2012
Tainted Chicken Jerky Treats Are Still on the Shelves of Many Retailers Despite Numerous Reports of Sickened Pets

CLEVELAND, OH— Following an increase in tainted pet treats from China leading to animal deaths and illnesses, U.S. Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH) is urging the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to take quick action to protect consumers and pet owners. At a news conference today in Cleveland, Brown was joined by Kevin Thaxton, whose 10 year-old pug, Chancey, passed away unexpectedly after eating chicken jerky pet treats. After Mr. Thaxton’s new five-month old puppy, Penny suffered life-threatening kidney failure after eating the same treats, the Thaxton’s saw an FDA warning connecting the illnesses between the two dogs: tainted chicken jerky pet treats imported from China.

“One of my most important jobs as Senator is fulfilling constituent services—from helping Ohioans cut red tape to assisting with government resources. Candace Thaxton, Kevin’s wife, wrote me a letter describing how their pug, Chancey, died as a result of kidney failure after eating chicken jerky treats that were made in China,” Brown said. “Unfortunately, their story is becoming too familiar—increasing amounts of tainted pet treats imported from China leading to deaths and illnesses in our nation’s pets. We’ve seen the same story play out with the food we eat—where too often we simply don’t know where ingredients come from. It’s critical that FDA also take swift action to protect consumers and pets from these tainted foods.

“Today, I’m calling on the FDA to step up its investigation of the importation of pet food—especially from China, where the possibility of food contamination is high,” Brown added. “Nationwide, approximately 62 percent of U.S. households own a pet. For so many Ohioans, including the many dog owners here today, caring for one is very personal. Families need to know that food and treats they purchase at local retailers are safe for their pets to consume.”

Today, Brown sent a letter to Commissioner of the FDA, Dr. Margaret Hamburg, urging the FDA to promptly pursue efforts to find the contaminant in these pet treats and ensure that they are pulled from store shelves. Brown asked the FDA to explain its current procedures for notifying consumers and retailers of pet food safety breaches.

“I urge you to promptly pursue efforts to find the contaminant in these pet foods, alert customers of the dangers of these products, and make sure the products found harmful are pulled from the retail market,” Brown wrote in the letter. “Please explain the FDA’s current procedure for notifying consumers, retailers, and manufacturers of pending investigations into possible pet food safety breaches.  Would a consumer who goes to the store to purchase dog treats have any way of knowing that a particular product is under review other than scouring the FDA’s website? How are retailers and manufacturers notified of potential concerns and what action is required on behalf of each party in response?”

Brown was also joined at the Cleveland Animal Protective League by veterinarian Dr. Brian Forsgren, and Karen Minton, the Humane Society of the United States’ Ohio state director, to call on the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to step up its investigation of pet food and treats, particularly those imported from countries like China, where the potential for contamination is high.
“The pet food recalls of 2007 exposed serious issues in our pet food supply. At HSUS alone, we received over 6,000 calls to our hotline in a short period of time from panicked pet owners who were concerned about what they were feeding their pets,” said Karen Minton. “While progress has been made, regular recalls of contaminated or unsafe pet food and treats continue, leaving pet owners concerned about which products they can trust. We commend Senator Brown for continuing to push this important issue to protect pets.”

Candace Thaxton wrote to Brown after her pug, Chancey, died as a result of kidney failure after eating chicken jerky treats that were made in China. Following the death of the Thaxton’s pug, the couple received a new puppy, Penny, from friends—and, not knowing that it was the chicken jerky treats that had sickened Chancey—fed the same treats to Penny. A Brooklyn Heights woman, Terry Safranek, lost her 9-year-old fox terrier, Samson, in late January. Only after seeing a story on the evening news did she realize that her dog’s death was likely due to his consumption of the same tainted chicken jerky treats.

Brown has been a strong advocate in the Senate for food safety, and was instrumental in passing the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Food Safety Modernization Act of 2010. As a member of the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee, he passed legislation to give the FDA new authority to recall dangerous foods, improve the safety of imported products, and establish a comprehensive traceability system to quickly and accurately trace the source of tainted food in the event of a food-borne illness outbreak.

The full letter to the FDA is below.

The Honorable Margaret H. Hamburg, M.D.
Commissioner
U.S. Food and Drug Administration
10903 New Hampshire Avenue
Silver Spring, MD 20993
Dear Commissioner Hamburg:
 
It has come to my attention that certain pet treats may be unfit for pets to consume.  Some pet owners in my home state of Ohio have reported that certain chicken jerky treats, particularly those made in China, have caused their dogs to suffer from symptoms such as decreased appetite and activity, vomiting, renal failure, and in some cases, death.  
 
I understand that the FDA is examining complaints from consumers and veterinarians and is working to determine the contaminant in these treats. To date, the FDA has not identified a contaminant and therefore they remain on the shelves of grocery markets and pet stores across the country.  The concern over pet food contamination is not without basis.  In recent years there have been sizable recalls of foreign-made pet food products due to contaminants including salmonella and melamine.    
 
I urge you to promptly pursue efforts to find the contaminant in these pet foods, alert customers of the dangers of these products, and make sure the products found harmful are pulled from the retail market.
 
Additionally, in your response, please explain the FDA’s current procedure for notifying consumers, retailers, and manufacturers of pending investigations into possible pet food safety breaches.  Would a consumer who goes to the store to purchase dog treats have any way of knowing that a particular product is under review other than scouring the FDA’s website? How are retailers and manufacturers notified of potential concerns and what action is required on behalf of each party in response?  
 
Thank you for all your efforts to protect public health and the safety of our nation’s pets.  I look forward to your swift actions and response.



Here is a video proveded by Fox8.com of the Thaxton family...


Please do the same as the Thaxton family.  Call or email the office of your Representatives in Congress and ask them to take the same action as Senator Sherrod Brown.  No more pets should die due to these imported jerky treats. 

Big THANKS to Mollie Morrisette for sending this information!

 

Wishing you and your pet(s) the best,

Susan Thixton
Pet Food Safety Advocate
Author, Buyer Beware
Co-Author Dinner PAWsible
TruthaboutPetFood.com
PetsumerReport.com


What's in Your Pet's Food?
Is your dog or cat eatipetsumerlogo.pngng risk ingredients?  Chinese imports?  Petsumer Report tells the 'rest of the story' on over 2500 cat foods, dog foods,  and pet treats.  30 Day Satisfaction Guarantee. www.PetsumerReport.com

Thelistimage2.jpg




The List
The List of pet foods that Susan wouldn't hesitate to feed to her own pets!





  Have you read Buyer Beware?






  Cooking for pets made easy, Dinner PAWsible.





Are you subscribed to Truth About Pet Food Newsletter?  Click Here to subscribe.

Follow Truth about Pet Food on Twitter. 

 Become a Fan of TruthVindication, Dinner PAWsible, Buyer Beware on Facebook.

Find Healthy Pet Foods in Your Area Click Here



Comments (22)

WickedCats
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 02:59 pm

This weekend I wanted to get my girl, Sofie some treats.  I was disappointed at how many bags I looked at that said they were from China.  The one thing that came to my head was, "Doesn't this country have chickens of it's own?"  I mean, I'm a vegetarian, but I know I have to give my pets meat!  And I worry about it all the time!  Why can't these pet food manufacturers make their own darn chicken treats?

 

itsgettingridiculous
Said this on 2-7-2012 At 07:44 am

Everything in this entire country is from China now...it's sad & pathetic. We have large corporations to thank for being so cheap they cant help out the ppl of their own country w/jobs & QUALITY goods & the government for allowing extra tax & shipping breaks (like they pay taxes in the 1st place!) to do so.

Richard Hartt
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 03:20 pm

Is this common with all the treats that come in from China such as the duck treats as well.  I just noticed that all of the duck treats that he has are from China.  He can only eat duck and venison and turkey because of allergies to chicken, lamb etc....

 

Susan Thixton
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 03:26 pm

I've heard from pet parents with sick pets from the duck treats too.  I wouldn't take a chance.

AnniQ
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 03:24 pm

Pat, pat, pat - There, there - Tut, tut. Now be good commercial pet food consumers and keep deluding yourself that any of that bagged. canned. boxed crap is actually safe for your pet. And the FDA lectured by some Midwest Senator is not going to do anything. 

From China or not, commercial pet food is some of the worst garbage junk food-industry get-rid-of-my waste #%&@ made for consumption by any living thing.

It's not that time-consuming to include a pet's daily diet preparation right along with yours. And if you plan ahead and freeze, you don't have to do it every day, except thaw the bag in water & serve!

 

christine
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 03:29 pm

It's very difficlut for retailers these days to source US made chicken and beef products as the demand is so high. Big corporations like Tyson are getting into the pet treat business and have bought up supply for things like beef tendons and bully sticks, as well as chicken for treats. The smaller US suppliers that we use in our retail store are overwhelmed with demand - it takes many weeks to fulfill our orders as the supply is more limited than you think, it seems. Americans eat more meat than in other countries, and we want American made in our pet treats as well - I think there's trouble meeting the demand, and the price is 3X as high of course as the Chinese stuff. A lot of people won't pay what is necessary to buy from companies that source from within countries that pay fair wages and expect excellent care of the animals that are used for the treats. People sure seem like they're hearing the message though about Chinese treats which is good, but it's very difficult for us to keep US treats in stock. Makes it hard for everyone!

christine
Said this on 3-17-2012 At 07:09 pm

I just wanted to clarify that we do not stock anything edible made in China - when I reread this comment I worried that people would think that I was saying retailers are stocking made in China jerky because it's hard to find other products, which isn't true. I was responding to the laments of people who were saying they couldn't find USA chicken jerky when they went to look - thought I'd offer some of what's going on in the US market.

J King
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 03:35 pm

Don't get me wrong, I'm ecstatic that a US government official has come up to bat for pets, however:  Nobody should have to appeal to their senator to make the FDA do its job.

Susan Thixton
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 03:56 pm

Isn't that the truth!  Great point.

Nance
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 03:51 pm

Nice to know someone is standing up for our pets. After reading all this on the chicken jerky from China I contacted Canyon Creek Ranch as I had purchased their chicken tenders treats and asked them if they could assure me they hadn't imported the chicken from China. They advertise on the package as being an American "owned" cmpany.  I got no reply to the question so assuming their products are imported and I tossed a very expensive bag of dog treats in the garbage rather than take a chance on harming my dogs. Be nice if the labels on the packages indicated the country of origin.

Susan Thixton
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 03:57 pm

Sometimes, but not always, treats that are imported from China (meat treats) have a radura symbol on the label.  Here's more information on that:  http://www.truthaboutpetfood.com/articles/another-reminder-do-you-know-what-this-symbol-means.html

 

next-time
Said this on 2-16-2012 At 08:42 am

Q: Where are these treats made?

 A: These treats are made in China at facilities that meet U.S. Department of Agriculture standards for quality and safety. In China, dark meat chicken is more popular with consumers than white meat chicken, and so the supply of quality, white meat chicken used in our products is more readily available for dog treats. The factories are under stringent safety and sanitary guidelines and monitored by a dedicated team of quality control inspectors, who are in the plants where the products are being produced. The benefit to our consumers is a premium dog treat at an affordable price.  http://www.canyoncreektreats.com/faq.html

probably doesn't mean diddly squat

Bama Griz
Said this on 3-13-2012 At 05:03 am

Canyon Creek Ranch says right on the labels "Made in China".

Said this on 2-6-2012 At 03:52 pm

It takes more than a commitment to "never buy" products from China; you have to trust the retailer where you shop, and develop a relationship.

I live near an area that is exceptionally high income.  I spoke with a woman recently, who worked for a notable local "natural" pet food retailer.  She stopped working there because, in her own words, "I could not take it any longer."  The manager had her removing the "made in China" labels from the rawhide bones and other products, and putting them in a "made in USA" display.

Lonnie
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 04:07 pm

thank you..mollie
Im a loyal TaPF follower....I also work in a pet food store that sells several varieties of these so called treats. When I see customers with this product, I make a point of letting them know the FDA has issued 3 warnings and the potential dangers.   Sadly...9 of 10 customers simply dismiss my casual warning.

Ignorance is bliss for most and extremely frustrating for the others.
side note: I was really disapointed to see Dogswell brand sourced from china...bummer

Said this on 2-6-2012 At 04:51 pm

First off, I am not a "pet parent"...I am a pet owner, with a couple of glorious Samoyeds and three spoiled rotten cats.

Regarding Chinese products, we avoid them in our house when/wherever possible, just on principle. If it means we pay a few dollars more, we save up and we pay it, rather than see more American jobs going to China.

That said, let us look at actual parents of actual children in China itself, who have died as a result of tainted milk and other consumables. They don't care about their own children...why would they care about our pets? Seriously.

Then as an "answer", when the producers get busted and exposed, the government kills them in a sick attempt to make itself look as if it's on top of this stuff. In fact, it is business as usual, nudge-nudge-wink-wink-say-no-more....as long as no one is looking and nobody's child inconveniently dies from melamine or other contamination in its food or milk.

Revolting.

Ethics are what one practices when one KNOWS that no one else is watching...not when we see someone looking and want to save our own hides. Dead Chinese babies and dead American pets are simply not acceptable collateral damage in corporate pursuit of the almighty dollar (or yen)...not ever.

We feed grain free kibble and raw meat/bones here to our pets, and the kibble is decreasing. I prefer to have as much control as possible over what goes into the mouths of my pets; they can't make the choice, so it is all on me to look out for them and protect their health & welfare. That's my job as a responsible pet owner.

I have carefully educated my puppy people about nutrition, point them to this site and to the Whole Dog Journal, the BARF Samoyed list, and other sources of education and information. I don't want them mindlessly following what the pet food & supply industry, me, or even their vet tells them. My mantra is "know for yourself!"

This may not be the most politically correct post your forum has ever received, but it is my viewpoint and I felt called to share it.

Thank you for all the work you do. It is not in vain! :-)

Said this on 2-6-2012 At 06:48 pm

Sherrod Brown, my Ohio senator, will add his strong voice to the many who remind the FDA that we are not happy with their approach to pet food safety.  Here is a scary note I just received: President Obama appointed former Monsanto vice president and lobbyist Michael Taylor as senior advisor to the Food and Drug Administration commissioner; go here for more info: http://www.moveon.org/r?r=269891&id=35461-7803489-qhguVfx&t=2 (if I can't add links please delete it... thanks.)

Stacy
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 06:56 pm

I am so concerned I just opened a new pack of treats my dog got for Christmas on Monday and on Wed my dog started vomiting by Friday night she was near death.. she is slowly getting better it seems Im going right home to check what the treats are..

jb
Said this on 2-6-2012 At 07:08 pm

I don't get.  It's so easy to buy a cheap food dehydrator, $20 & buy chicken, beef, turkey & organ meats, slice it & dry it.

No Big Deal.  Then you know what you companions are eating.

Heather
Said this on 2-7-2012 At 03:25 pm

You are so right JB, there are lots of recipes out there for treats. At least if you make them yourself you know what is in them. I wouldn't trust labels as I don't think they are honest and you have to do a lot of digging to find out where the ingredients really come from.

Said this on 2-6-2012 At 08:50 pm

There are very few commercial foods my pets eat, & all checked very carefully ! Its not that hard to make their food or treats, spend a few hours 1 weekend & freeze the extras. Still no guarantee on safety since all food is suspect, but at least you know where & how is was made .

Susan
Said this on 2-14-2012 At 12:25 pm

One of my dogs nearly died three days after eating Milo's Chicken Jerky. They diagnosed it as HGE, but now I can't help but wonder.

Post a Comment (showhide)
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
(not publicly displayed)
Reply Notification:
Approval Notification:
Website:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image:
* Message:

Email to Friend

Fill in the form below to send this article to a friend:

Email to Friend
* Your Name:
* Your Email:
* Friend's Name:
* Friend's Email:
* Security Image:
Security Image Generate new
Copy the numbers and letters from the security image
* Message: